Our reviews
Reviews from Grubhub
Richard
2 reviews
The pizza I ordered from Motorino was absolutely delicious. I have been to a lot of the top rated pizza places in NYC and Motorino is certainly up there with the best. Thank you so much
Maryanne
Top Reviewer
The food is simply delicious, I ordered the octopus salad and roasted artichokes and both were exceptional!! I highly recommend this restaurant
Tiffany
Top Reviewer
The food here is always delicious. The Octopus salad is amazing and a great portion for $15. One of my favorite places to order on GrubHub.
Monique
Top Reviewer
Pizza was excellent. I would order the Caesar with the dressing on the side because my salad was over-dressed,
kim
1 review
We will definitely order again. Fantastic flavors and textures. And good the next day as left overs too.
Reviews from Seamless.com
Evan
1 review
Other than the pizza being dynamite, they made things right when mistakenly gave my order to my neighbor (who ate it instead of saying they didn't order it). There's something to be said about businesses who focus their efforts on making the customer happy instead of worrying about blame. I'll keep ordering bc the food rocks, they are almost always timely, and they focus on making sure the customer is satisfied.
David
Top Reviewer
The UWS has been missing a stellar Pizza Joint for a LONG time. Sal & Carmine's, and Numero 28 the closest we have had to even half way decent pie, so the addition of Motorino is AWESOME and highly appreciated by all long time residents. Motorino is widely considered in the top 15 in the City, and I highly suggest going for the Clam Pie. Welcome to the Upper West!
Renee
Top Reviewer
After always ordering common place pizza, we tried decided to try this. It was fantastic!
We always re-warm pizzas on a hot stone in the oven when they are delivered. This crust was anazing, the toppings were fresh and vibrant, and I will be ordering here rather than any other pizza place Ive tried on the upper West side.
We always re-warm pizzas on a hot stone in the oven when they are delivered. This crust was anazing, the toppings were fresh and vibrant, and I will be ordering here rather than any other pizza place Ive tried on the upper West side.
Kathy
3 reviews
Great Pizza But the app with say the time is much less, you need to check with restaurant estimate. On a Friday night in peak hours it will take 90 min.
Tim
Top Reviewer
A tad late but best pizza ever and delivered hot.
If you're used to Australian quality food this is one the few UWS places that satisfies.
If you're used to Australian quality food this is one the few UWS places that satisfies.